Book Review: Charlie Milverton and Other Sherlock Holmes Stories

Charlie Milverton and Other Sherlock Holmes Stories

by Charlotte Anne Walters

Reviewed by Amy Thomas, The Baker Street Babes

Charlie Milverton Cover

Charlie Milverton, a collection of five Sherlock Holmes stories, is certainly a book of its time. Prior to 2010, modernized Holmes stories existed, but the inception and meteoric rise of Sherlock and Elementary have brought the idea into vogue in an unprecedented way. Author Charlotte Anne Walters has chosen to turn her pen toward bringing this phenomenon back to the printed page.

Charlotte isn’t at all cagey about her source material. Titles like “The Premier Bachelor” give broad hints of the stories she’s chosen to update, and her plots come directly from Doyle. What she’s chosen to change are contexts, and, to some extent, characters. Individuals like Charlie Milverton are recognizable as updates of their canon counterparts, but their qualities and vocations are at home in the modern world.

The style of the writing is fast-paced and very plot driven. Readers won’t find themselves getting bored. The prominence of Lestrade’s character is unexpected but certainly welcome and enjoyably executed.

As a devoted watcher of Sherlock, there have been moments throughout the series when I thought the modernization of a particular aspect rang less true than it should, particularly in “The Blind Banker.” I found myself experiencing a similar feeling occasionally when reading Charlie Milverton, as a Victorian-sounding line here and there jarred slightly with my immersion into the stories’ modern world.

Overall, Charlie Milverton is an interesting project that asks whether or not a Sherlock Holmes story can be translated as directly as Walters has chosen to do and succeed as a modern story. Barring the occasional odd moment, I would say the answer is yes; it works.

Charlie Milverton and other Sherlock Holmes Stories is available from all good bookstores including   Amazon USA, Amazon UK, Waterstones UK, and for free shipping worldwide Book Depository . In ebook format it is in Amazon KindleKobo, Nook and Apple iBooks (iPad/iPhone).

A copy of the above-reviewed work was provided for consideration by the publisher. All opinions expressed are the reviewer’s own.

Book Review: Charlie Milverton and Other Sherlock Holmes Stories

Charlie Milverton and Other Sherlock Holmes Stories by Charlotte Anne Walters Reviewed by Amy Thomas, The Baker Street Babes Charlie Milverton, a collection of five Sherlock Holmes stories, is certainly a book of its time. Prior to 2010, modernized Holmes stories existed, but the inception and meteoric rise of Sherlock and Elementary have brought the idea into vogue in an… Read More »

Elementary Review 02 x 20 – No Lack of Void

Jonny Lee Miller is underrated. I understand that the Cumberbatch shadow is nearly as large as that of a 40 story sky scraper, but the man is killing it week after week and No Lack of Void was a shining example of how he is evolving this character into something so much more than a… Read More »

Elementary 02 x 19 – The Many Mouths of Aaron Colville

So things got in the way of this review and for that, I apologize. You know, nerdy things, Sherlock things. 221B Con was a big success and I am better you’ll all love the live podcast from the Con in the weeks to come. Then there were the Shorty Awards, which we didn’t win, but… Read More »

221b Con 2014

April 3-6, 2014: Atlanta, Georgia. Fan cons are an amazing thing. First, they start as a simple idea of a date and location. Before our eyes, they grow shape and content through the collaboration of organizers and interested fans. It’s not until you get there, though, that the magic overtakes you. Last year’s inaugural 221b… Read More »

Podcaster Finalist At The Shorty Awards, TONIGHT!

The Shorty Awards are tonight! And we’re up for Best Podcaster. After lots of campaigning and tons of love, we were announced as finalists in the podcaster category. The fact is, we never would have gotten there without all of you. To all of you who shared the campaign, who tweeted nominations, or who just… Read More »

Episode 55: Tony Lee

[LISTEN] | [DOWNLOAD] (Save Link As) —————————————— Kafers and Taylor traveled to Birmingham to attend Starfury’s Elementary Con and interview New York Times Best Selling author Tony Lee on one of the panels. The girls and Tony discuss Sherlock Holmes, Tony’s deep and abiding love for Professor Moriarty, and talk everything writing from ideas to… Read More »

The Babes at 221B Con! Where to find us + live podcast info!

  We are absolutely delighted to announce the Baker Street Babes’ 221B Con schedule of appearances and podcast topic! Sunday at 10:00 am is our live podcast! The topic at hand will be: Ashley Polasek and Sherlockian Film Since 1900 Ashley Polasek is an “Aca-Sherlockian,” happily living at the crossroads of academia, traditional Sherlockiana, and contemporary… Read More »

Episode 54: The Detective, The Woman and The Silent Hive

[LISTEN] | [DOWNLOAD] (Save Link As) —————————————— BSB Amy has a new book! Silent Hive is a new story about Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler that ties into Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original story “The Five Orange Pips.” We chat to her about what it’s like having three pastiches out, a LOT about The Five Orange… Read More »

The Detective, The Woman and The Silent Hive

  BSB Amy has a new book coming out! Launching March 18th, Silent Hive is a new story about Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler that ties into Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original story “The Five Orange Pips,” but you don’t need to have read that story to enjoy it. Amy has previously written The Detective and… Read More »

Elementary Review: 02 x 18 – The Hound of the Cancer Cells

After nearly two seasons and more than forty episodes, for the first time ever, I was thoroughly creeped out by a murder on Elementary this week. Helium death not only sounds creepy, it is remarkably simple to pull off. And while I found myself comparing the hallucinogenic effects described and seen in BBC’s Sherlock and… Read More »