Book Review: The Case Books of Octavius Bear

Book Review: The Case Books of Octavius Bear

Reviewed by Amy Thomas

open amd shut

This is a review of the first two books in an ongoing series by author Harry DeMaio, The Open and Shut Case and The Case of the Spotted Band. To be perfectly honest, when I received these novels, I had absolutely no idea what to expect. The extent of my knowledge was that this series features anthropomorphic animals and is inspired by Sherlock Holmes.

Are they for children? I wondered. Can I, in any way, take them seriously? What is the purpose of doing this? Then I opened the first one and started reading.

No, these books are not children’s literature, they are serious without being self-important, and their purpose is, at least as I see it, to create a whole new world that is somehow deliciously reminiscent of the Holmes canon we know and love.

DeMaio’s attention to detail throughout the books is staggering. Understanding the challenge of jumping into a world in which Sherlock Holmes, professor Moriarty, and their cohorts are represented by animals, he includes in each book a character guide and a short explanation of how his post-apocalyptic animal society works.

The only book I can think of that is in any way comparable is the classic Watership Down by Richard Adams. Like DeMaio, Adams used animals to represent and illuminate aspects of human society. To my eye, the Octavius Bear books have the same amount of potential to become classics in the world of Sherlock Holmes-inspired fiction.

DeMaio is a skilled and engaging storyteller and crafter of characters and mystery narrative. Those who enjoy traditional Holmesian works will enjoy his books. It’s not a matter of trying to get past a concept to find the story; he manages to make his animals and their world an intrinsic part of his unique Sherlockian vision.

Somehow, through Octavius Bear and his associates, Harry DeMaio has managed to create something that is entirely new and entirely familiar. His world is a very enjoyable place to lose yourself.

————-

The Open and Shut Case is available from all good bookstores including  Amazon USA , Amazon UK ,Waterstones UK , and for free shipping worldwide Book Depository .  In ebook format it is in Kindle, Kobo,Nook and Apple iBooks (iPad/iPhone).
The Case of The Spotted Band is available from all good bookstores including  Amazon USA, Amazon UK,Waterstones UK, and for free shipping worldwide Book Depository .  In ebook format it is in Kindle, Kobo,Nook and Apple iBooks (iPad/iPhone).

The books reviewed above were provided for consideration by the publisher. All opinions expressed are the reviewer’s own. 

Book Review: The Case Books of Octavius Bear

Book Review: The Case Books of Octavius Bear Reviewed by Amy Thomas This is a review of the first two books in an ongoing series by author Harry DeMaio, The Open and Shut Case and The Case of the Spotted Band. To be perfectly honest, when I received these novels, I had absolutely no idea what to expect…. Read More »

Episode 63: Robert Doherty

——————————————————— [DOWNLOAD] | [LISTEN] | [iTUNES] Elementary creator, executive producer, and writer Robert Doherty joins BSBs Liz and Amy to discuss the upcoming finale of the third season of the hit CBS show about Sherlock Holmes and Joan Watson in modern day New York City. Elementary stars Jonny Lee Miller as Holmes and Lucy Liu… Read More »

SherlockeDCC Returns To San Diego Comic Con!

San Diego Comic Con is the biggest party of the year, so what better place is there to have the biggest Sherlock Holmes bash of the year? SherlockeDCC is BACK (IN TIME)! Once again we’ve got the entire 9th floor of the stunning San Diego Public Library to ourselves, complete with two balconies overlooking PETCO… Read More »

Special #14: 221B Con Live With Ben Syder

——————————————————— [DOWNLOAD] | [LISTEN] | [iTUNES] Asylum’s Sherlock Holmes is the best Sherlock Holmes adaptation of all time. I mean, what other Holmes film has him battling a mechanical dragon while in a dirigible/hot air balloon with a gatling gun?! NONE! We lucky ladies got to sit down and chat with Ben Syder, who played… Read More »

BSB Live & Local 2: Jeremy Strong

——————————————————— [DOWNLOAD] | [LISTEN] | [iTUNES] Welcome to Baker Street Babes Live and Local, coming to you from the University of West London! Most Sherlockians have picked up a pastiche or read some fanfic, but the long shadow of Sherlock Holmes reaches so much further than stories that feature him. The relationship of Holmes and… Read More »

Get Your Victorian Swag On At 221B Con!

HEY 221B CON!!! We’re throwing a party! A #VictorianSwag party at 221B Con! We’re going to have music, candy, games, and a nice lounge for you to come and chill in! Come on by to hang before the craziness of Saturday night! Every attendee gets free prints and stickers! When: Saturday, April 11th from 5-7PM… Read More »

Book Review: Further Encounters of Sherlock Holmes edited by George Mann

Further Encounters of Sherlock Holmes Edited by George Mann Reviewed by Ardy Much like boxes of chocolates, typically, short story collections can be a bit of a risk: what if half the box consists of those weird coconut-filled chocolates I can’t actually eat? I am delighted to say that Further Encounters of Sherlock Holmes is… Read More »

Elementary Review 03 x 17 – T-Bone and the Iceman

It’s been a while since Elementary veered straight into crime procedural territory, but it’s hard to imagine this story not fitting in basically every single iteration of CSI. A man with cancer commits a murder in hopes of eventually stealing cryogenically frozen cord blood to treat his condition. Unfortunately, the less than stellar business practices of… Read More »

Elementary Review 03 x 16 – For All You Know

When Sherlock has to investigate himself, things get weird on Elementary. Holmes is suspected of murdering a woman and burying her in Central Park during his addiction days, but he can’t remember any of the details of the case. It’s a dark past full of missed connections and old relationships gone awry, but it’s also… Read More »

New book on the world of Sherlock Holmes out in German

  Here is something for the German and German speaking Sherlock Holmes fans: BSB Maria has written an introduction to the world of Sherlock Holmes in German. The contents of the book cover the early writing career of Arthur Conan Doyle and his various sources and inspirations for the characters of the Canon. A detailed… Read More »