Book Review: Otto Penzler (Ed.): Sherlock – Over 80 Stories Starring the Greatest Detective of All Time

sherlock book cover smol

Sherlock – Over 80 Stories Starring the Greatest Detective of All Time

Selected and Edited by Otto Penzler

Reviewed by Maria

The volume seems a little overwhelming when you first hold it in your hands. The UK hardcover edition consists of almost 900 pages and holds 83 Sherlock Holmes stories selected by Otto Penzler. (The US Version is called The Big Book of Sherlock Holmes Stories and has fewer pages, but the same content). After an introduction by Penzler, the book starts off with an interview by Arthur Conan Doyle from 1900 (his justification of killing Holmes in “The Final Problem” and some comments on the Great Detective) and two of his non-canonical Sherlock Holmes stories. Followed by the most famous short story pastiches and parodies, including Vincent Starrett’s “The Unique ‘Hamlet’” and J.M. Barrie’s satirical “The Adventure of the Two Collaborators” and Stephen King’s “The Doctor’s Case”.

The rest of the book consists of stories that range from pastiches that are very close to the Canon to further parodies, to stories laden with intertextual references to other stories, literary characters (Raffles or Poirot) or even Arthur Conan Doyle himself while others are only very loosely related to Sherlock Holmes. Not all of the stories are good and only very few are actually brilliant, but most of the 83 stories are quite entertaining, written with love for the original, and a lovely addition to the Canon.

My personal favourites are Vincent Starrett’s “The Unique ‘Hamlet’” (yes, that’s the same man who write the book The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes and the sonnet “Always 1895” aka. “221B”), J.M. Barrie’s “The Late Sherlock Holmes”, a wonderful metafictional account of the arrest of Dr Watson as the main suspect in the death of Sherlock Holmes at the Reichenbach Falls published immediately after “The Final Problem” with a very telling conclusion which may or may not have influenced Doyle to pick up writing more Holmes stories in 1903. I also loved Antony Burgess’s “Murder to Music”, Lyndsay Faye’s “The Case of Colonel Warburton’s Madness” (I promise I am not biased. Lyndsay successfully wrote Holmes pastiches long before she became a Baker Street Babe – for instance Dust and Shadow and the story printed in this volume) and Logan Clendening’s “The Case of the Missing Patriarchs” in which Holmes after his death is employed to find Adam and Eve, who have disappeared which made me laugh harder than it probably should have.

However, those are just a few of many wonderful stories in this book and what they all have in common is the fantastic notion that Holmes lives on in manifold ways, universes, interpretations and forms. It shows that from the very beginning Sherlock Holmes has inspired both earnest pastiches and hilarious parodies and while many of the authors are known for their love of Sherlock Holmes some other names will be a surprise to the reader.

Apart from the stories, this book also features a short introductory text by Otto Penzler about the author and the context of each story, featuring interesting trivia titbits like the fact that Doyle, Barrie, Wodehouse and others had formed a cricket club, but Doyle was the only person who could actually play cricket. There short introductions add tremendously to an already fascinating and wonderful collection.

The UK publisher of the book, Head of Zeuz, has kindly offered us a copy of Sherlock to give away to one of our readers. This giveaway is currently for the UK only. All you have to do is leave a comment until February 7 on this post on our website and we will draw a random winner from all of those who commented.

The book is currently on sale on amazon.co.uk  and bookdepository and can also be purchased at amazon.de.

The US version can be purchased on amazon.com, where it is also currently on sale!

Book Review: Otto Penzler (Ed.): Sherlock – Over 80 Stories Starring the Greatest Detective of All Time

Sherlock – Over 80 Stories Starring the Greatest Detective of All Time Selected and Edited by Otto Penzler Reviewed by Maria The volume seems a little overwhelming when you first hold it in your hands. The UK hardcover edition consists of almost 900 pages and holds 83 Sherlock Holmes stories selected by Otto Penzler. (The… Read More »

Book Review: Rose Shepherd: Sherlock Holmes’s London – Explore the City in the Footsteps of the Great Detective

Sherlock Holmes’s London – Explore the City in the Footsteps of the Great Detective By Rose Shepherd Reviewed by Maria As so often with Sherlockian Publications these days, Sherlock Holmes’s London is immediately remarkable for its beautiful cover. I know that one should not jump to conclusions from that alone, but the iconic profile of… Read More »

Book Review: The Sherlock Holmes Book edited by David Stuart Davies and Barry Forshaw

The Sherlock Holmes Book Edited by David Stuart Davies and Barry Forshaw Reviewed by Maria October 1st saw the release of The Sherlock Holmes Book, a lovely heavy book whose cover already hints at the incredible amount of information between the covers (the US release is on October 20). It’s part of the series Big… Read More »

Book Review: Investigating Sherlock – The Unofficial Guide by Nikki Stafford

Investigating Sherlock – The Unofficial Guide by Nikki Stafford Reviewed by Maria Fleischhack   Nikki Stafford’s book is a little treasure chest filled with bits of information which will make any Sherlock BBC fan smile. Since the airing of Sherlock, Tumblr and other internet platforms have been rife with discussions about the actors, characters, Canon-… Read More »

Book Review: The Early Punch Parodies of Sherlock Holmes

The Early Punch Parodies of Sherlock Holmes By Bill Peschel Reviewed by Maria  We all love the Sherlock Holmes stories and yet we will all freely admit that they are often flawed, sometimes unintentionally funny and every no and then too far-fetched to be entirely believable. It’s therefore not surprising that even while the original… Read More »

Book Review: Sherlock Holmes – The Man Who Never Lived and Will Never Die

Sherlock Holmes – The Man Who Never Lived and Will Never Die – The Museum of London Companion to the Exhibition review by BSB Maria When I received a review copy of the catalogue of/companion book to the Sherlock Holmes exhibition at the Museum of London, my first impression was that it is impossibly pretty…. Read More »

Femme Friday: Violet Hunter

Violet Hunter By BSB Sarah It’s time for another Femme Friday! Today we need to talk about the awesomeness that is Violet Hunter. Miss Hunter is the client in “The Copper Beeches”, the final story in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes. In addition to introducing us to this lady who knows she is pretty darn rockin’ and… Read More »

Femme Friday: Irene Adler

Irene Adler By BSB Lyndsay Irene Adler means many things to many people.  For some, she is the first truly legendary antagonist faced by Sherlock Holmes.  (Because really…do you spend much time ruminating over errant Mormons?  Does Jonathan Small get your panties in a twist?) For others, she is a plucky ringlet-haired sass machine who is allowed to tweak… Read More »

Femme Friday: Lady Mary Brackenstall

Lady Mary Brackenstall By BSB Ashley Welcome back to Femme Friday, and let us introduce you to one of the most stalwart women in the entire canon: Lady Mary Brackenstall. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was not always a man of progressive ideals: he was anti-suffragist and pro-imperialist, a British gentleman of traditional sensibilities in many ways…. Read More »

Canon Thursday: Desert Island Holmes Top 5

 You’re marooned on a desert island, and you can only take five Sherlock Holmes stories with you. Regardless of length (novel or short story) and original publication chronology, which five stories would you bring along to be your companions and why? (Keep in mind that if you meet a friendly native, these five stories will… Read More »