Arthur & George: Episode 3 Recap and Review

DOYLE 2014 LTD FOR  ITV ARTHUR & GEORGE Pictured: MARTIN CLUNES as Arthur and ARSHER ALI as George. These images are the copyright of ITV/DOYLE 2014 LTD.


Reviewed by Amy


The finale episode of Arthur & George brought the series to new heights in almost every area and left me wishing the entire series had been as well-written and tightly-plotted as Episode 3 was.

The story picked up at a perplexing moment, in which Sir Arthur had begun to have serious doubts about Edalji’s innocence and some of the seeming coincidences of the case. By doggedly following the clues, much like Holmes would have done, Doyle and his secretary finally uncovered the truth about a troubled young man and a grudge that had existed since childhood.

The series didn’t follow the narrative to the very end, but text-on-screen assured the viewer that Edalji was fully exonerated and resumed his work as a solicitor. From a character standpoint, Doyle’s forensic victory lightened his emotional load and gave him the impetus to declare his true feelings for Jean Leckie and become engaged to her.

The episode left a few perplexing questions, notably about oddities of Edalji’s life that were never explained. Most of these appear to be casualties of a total series runtime of only a little over two hours, and interested viewers can find answers is Arthur & George by Julian Barnes, on which the show is based.

Overall, Episode 3 dramatically increased my admiration for the series as a whole, and while I still believe the cast deserves the lion’s share of credit for making it all work, the subtlety and coherence of Ed Whitmore’s conclusion deserve a mention as well.

Arthur & George has been an enjoyable, if imperfect, look at a lesser-known event in an author’s life, one that had major historical implications in Britain (the creation of the criminal appeals court). A few more episodes would have fleshed out the details more, but as it stands, a stellar cast put heart and polish into a good script and created a series that will no doubt charm Holmesian audiences for some time to come.

The series is currently available for streaming at

amybioAmy Thomas is one of the Baker Street Babes and one of the review team. Have something you’d like her to review? Email her at

I am a knitting fiend and book reviewer with a degree in professional communication, as well as the author of three Sherlock Holmes novels in the Detective and The Woman series.

Arthur & George: Episode 3 Recap and Review

  Reviewed by Amy   The finale episode of Arthur & George brought the series to new heights in almost every area and left me wishing the entire series had been as well-written and tightly-plotted as Episode 3 was. The story picked up at a perplexing moment, in which Sir Arthur had begun to have serious doubts… Read More »

Arthur & George Episode 2 Recap and Review

  Reviewed by Amy After last week’s origin story, it was refreshing to go deeper into the Edalji case this week in part two of this three-part series. In my opinion, some of the awkwardness of last week’s script was gone, and the story moved through the investigation a bit more seamlessly. At the same… Read More »

Huge New Sherlock Holmes Anthology

                                      Today, the Radio Times announced the upcoming publication of a new Sherlock Holmes anthology that will contain a record-breaking 60 stories and be published in three volumes. Two of the contributors are Babes Lyndsay Faye and Amy Thomas,… Read More »

With His Boots On: A Tribute to Sir Christopher Lee

I awoke this morning to news of a most unwelcome kind, that of the passing of Sir Christopher Lee. Given that he had reached the age of 93, it’s impossible to say that Sir Christopher passed away before his time, but somehow it still feels true. Born in 1922, Christopher Lee, long before the Sir… Read More »

Pastiche vs Fanfiction: The Debate That Wouldn’t Die

A few years ago, I wrote a piece laying out my viewpoint that pastiche is anything Sherlock Holmes-themed that is faithful to Doyle’s characters. Since then, my opinion has evolved and changed. I’m going to re-articulate it. Just today, I Hear of Sherlock Everywhere published this piece, which does a great job of explaining the viewpoint… Read More »

Femme Friday: Effie Munro and Lucy Hebron

The Yellow Face: Effie Munro and Her Daughter Lucy Hebron By BSB Amy                 “The Yellow Face,” along with several other canonical Holmes stories, presents unavoidable difficulties for modern readers. In fact, at a recent convention, my fellow panelist suggested that this story should never even be printed. Before I get into the specifics of… Read More »

Femme Friday: Molly Hooper

Molly Hooper By BSB Amy Long, straight hair, lipstick that comes and goes, and an ironically macabre career—exploring unassuming but totally awesome Molly Hooper is a journey that starts with specific stories framed by the creators of the BBC’s Sherlock, finds its anchor in the Sherlock Holmes canon as a whole, and winds up the wider genre of… Read More »

Book Review: Jewel of the Thames

 Jewel of the Thames By Angela Misri Reviewed by Amy Thomas, The Baker Street Babes I’m a happy book reviewer. A lot of times, when I review Holmesian literature, I come out with one of two perspectives: Either a book is a respectable pastiche but lags or is stilted in writing style, or it’s entertainingly… Read More »

Episode 54: The Detective, The Woman and The Silent Hive

[LISTEN] | [DOWNLOAD] (Save Link As) —————————————— BSB Amy has a new book! Silent Hive is a new story about Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler that ties into Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original story “The Five Orange Pips.” We chat to her about what it’s like having three pastiches out, a LOT about The Five Orange… Read More »

Canon Thursday: Desert Island Holmes Top 5

 You’re marooned on a desert island, and you can only take five Sherlock Holmes stories with you. Regardless of length (novel or short story) and original publication chronology, which five stories would you bring along to be your companions and why? (Keep in mind that if you meet a friendly native, these five stories will… Read More »