Book Review: The Murder of Sherlock Holmes by David Fable

the murder of sherlock holmes

The Murder of Sherlock Holmes

by David Fable

Reviewed by Maria Fleischhack

Sherlock Holmes has died and John Watson makes the heartbreaking decision to investigate what he believes is murder. The novel’s premises already indicated a strong diversion from the Canon, and yet it begins in typical fashion, with John Watson as the narrator. However, this time he is not alone in that venture. Scotland Yard, particularly Inspector Lestrade, and, more importantly, the young Christopher Hudson support him in what he believes to be his final case. Christopher is Mrs Hudson’s son whom Holmes had trained in his profession, even though he was sent to medical school by his mother. He throws himself into the case to find out who killed his idol.

Set in 1912, David Fable creates an alternative universe for the characters of Arthur Conan Doyle’s stories. Fable’s book is split into two narrative strands – John Watson’s usual first person account is interwoven with Christopher Hudson’s narrative of the events. Very soon, it becomes clear that The Murder of Sherlock Holmes is not trying to imitate the canonical voice of Watson. The doctor seems a remnant of the Victorian age and young Hudson is depicted as a modern man who enjoys life to the fullest, preferring leather jackets to suits and driving a Harley Davidson through London. The story reads rather like a film and has little else but the setting and some of the characters in common with the Canon stories. Fable’s interpretation of the characters changes not only their behaviour (both Watson and Hudson often react to women with open animosity, foul language and sometimes unnecessary violence, something which is unthinkable in the Canon), but also strives to subvert Doyle’s narrative. Nothing is as it seems and John Watson is confronted with the realization that Holmes has kept some very private things from him, while James Moriarty becomes an unlikely ally in the case of Sherlock Holmes’s murder.

The book is fast paced and seems adamant at driving not only the plot, but also history forward. Brimming with side notes and references to turn of the century inventions, the reader occasionally feels like the book is trying to be both, novel and encyclopaedia of the advancements of the early 20th century at once. The most important canonical characters are present: James Moriarty, Mrs Hudson, the Scotland Yarders and the Baker Street Irregulars, who are all grown up now and a force to be reckoned with. Large parts of the narrative are concerned with the different ways in which Watson and Hudson deal with the death of Sherlock Holmes, while John Watson slowly gains an understanding of just how much the cards have been shuffled and redistributed.

While the novel itself is an enjoyable read, it doesn’t read like a typical Holmes pastiche – it is rather the opposite – a deconstruction of the Canon by giving the main characters greater weaknesses than Doyle ever did. The various failures, eccentricities and unlikable traits of the characters are visible throughout the book, just as London gains a rather claustrophobic quality, which creates an atmosphere that reminded me rather of Gotham City than Edwardian London.

The estrangement from the Canon also comes from the extensive use of US-American terminology and slang. Some rather unlikely elements, like Christopher Hudson driving around London in a Daimler (the company made the cars of the Royal families of Europe and provided busses, but for a normal middle class family to own one is incredibly unlikely, particularly since Christopher also owns a Harley Davidson) or the hundred and ten thousand pounds, which Holmes apparently had no issue obtaining from a bank (worth approximately 12 million Pound Sterling in 1912 and absolutely impossible to be simply picked up from a bank by an individual, even such an important individual as Sherlock Holmes) will be distracting to those who are familiar with the Canon and Edwardian England. The solution to the mystery is possibly the most drastic diversion from the Canon and seems a little too constructed and stereotypical to feel satisfactory.

The book is certainly entertaining, fast paced and complex, but I dare say that it is quite experimental and very different from what you would expect from a Sherlock Holmes pastiche.

(A review copy was kindly provided by the author)

You can purchase the novel at abebooks, amazon US, amazon UK, or any quality book store of your choice.

Book Review: The Murder of Sherlock Holmes by David Fable

The Murder of Sherlock Holmes by David Fable Reviewed by Maria Fleischhack Sherlock Holmes has died and John Watson makes the heartbreaking decision to investigate what he believes is murder. The novel’s premises already indicated a strong diversion from the Canon, and yet it begins in typical fashion, with John Watson as the narrator. However,… Read More »

Book Review: Blood to the Bone

Blood to the Bone (Fight Card) By Andrew Salmon Reviewed by Maria Fleischhack As promised in the review of Work Capitol, here follows the review of Andrew Salmon’s second Fight Card – Sherlock Holmes story, Blood to the Bone, a novel about women’s bare-knuckle boxing in the late nineteenth century. In the story, which is… Read More »

Book Review: Work Capitol

Work Capitol (Fight Card) By Andrew Salmon Reviewed by Maria Fleischhack As with most pastiches, the story told in this book is narrated by John Watson and it is one of those cases which have never been told before. Very often we encounter accidental finds or stories involving people whose names had to be protected… Read More »

Book Review: The Early Punch Parodies of Sherlock Holmes

The Early Punch Parodies of Sherlock Holmes By Bill Peschel Reviewed by Maria  We all love the Sherlock Holmes stories and yet we will all freely admit that they are often flawed, sometimes unintentionally funny and every no and then too far-fetched to be entirely believable. It’s therefore not surprising that even while the original… Read More »

Book Review: Ghosts of Manhattan

Ghosts of Manhattan By George Mann Reviewed by Ardy This is not a pastiche, but it was written by George Mann, author of The Spirit Box and editor of several anthologies of Holmes short stories. Set in an alternate New York in 1926, Ghosts of Manhattan mixes alternate-history steam/dieselpunk with hard-boiled detective fiction. There are… Read More »

Elementary Review: 03 x 05 Rip Off

When I learnt that “Rip Off” was an episode without Joan, I was disappointed. It is understandable that the writers needed to build the plot so that Lucy Liu could spend some time behind the camera, but removing one of the show’s protagonists for a whole episode had me questioning how well it would hang… Read More »

Elementary Review: 03 x 04 Bella

In the original stories, Sherlock Holmes often dealt with some odd cases: “The Speckled Band” comes to mind, as well as the most bizarre of all, “The Creeping Man” (the first rule of “The Creeping Man” is do not talk about “The Creeping Man”). Elementary has often steered away from the stranger side of Sherlock… Read More »

Elementary Review: 03 x 03 Just a Regular Irregular

The third episode of Elementary continues exploring how Sherlock’s sudden absence has affected his relationships, and once again poses questions about his ability to have and maintain meaningful friendships. So far the series has, naturally, focused on beginning the rebuild of Sherlock’s relationship with Joan. This episode opens this up a little, and asks whether… Read More »

Elementary Review: 03 x 02 The Five Orange Pipz

After the premiere promised that things would be shaken up a little in this season of Elementary, “The Five Orange Pipz” for the most part returned us to familiar territory. There is a murder at the episode’s beginning and an arrest at the episode’s end, and this conservatism is a little disappointing after the energy… Read More »

Elementary Review: 03 x 01 Enough Nemesis to Go Around

Elementary is back in business. After a mixed bag of a second season, where the writers seemed unsure about how to develop Sherlock and Joan’s relationship, the choice to separate them was an interesting one – the show’s greatest strength is in its characters and relationships, and the chemistry of Jonny Lee Miller and Lucy… Read More »